Building HR Policies Around Your Business

๐Ÿงญ Dojo Compass

Module: Leadership, People and Organizational Excellence

Focus Area: Organizational Design and Governance

Learning Format: Article

Human resource management is often treated as something that becomes important once a company reaches a certain size. In reality, the foundations of effective HR management should be established from the earliest stages of a business.

This article examines how SMEs can develop HR policies and procedures that support their strategic objectives while reflecting their actual organizational circumstances. It introduces a balanced approach combining top-down adoption of proven HR practices with bottom-up development based on the company’s own needs, dynamics and organizational DNA.

๐ŸŽฏ Key Challenge

From the moment a company hires its first employee, it begins creating an employment environment.

Decisions about recruitment, compensation, working hours, responsibilities, performance expectations, communication and employee development establish patterns that can eventually become part of the organization’s culture.

Yet many SMEs do not give sufficient attention to the development of a coherent HR framework during their early stages of growth.

There are several reasons for this.

Entrepreneurs are understandably focused on developing products, acquiring customers, generating revenue and managing cash flow. HR policies may appear to be an administrative necessity rather than a strategic priority.

Consequently, companies often adopt one of two approaches.

The first is to borrow established HR policies and procedures from larger organizations.

These may come from previous employers, industry templates, external consultants or commercially available HR manuals. Although these materials can provide useful guidance, they may have been designed for organizations with substantially different structures, resources, management capabilities and operational requirements.

A policy that works well in a multinational corporation with dedicated HR personnel may be unnecessarily complicated for a company employing fifteen people.

The result can be an impressive collection of documents that employees rarely consult, managers struggle to implement and the organization does not genuinely embrace.

The second approach is to develop HR practices informally as the company grows.

This can work reasonably well while the organization is small and employees interact directly with its founders or senior management.

However, informal arrangements can become increasingly problematic as the company expands.

Different managers may adopt inconsistent practices. Employees may receive different treatment in similar circumstances. Responsibilities and expectations may become unclear. Important employment matters may be addressed reactively rather than through established procedures.

The company can find itself operating with an HR framework that has evolved through individual decisions rather than deliberate design.

Both approaches have shortcomings.

The challenge is therefore to develop HR policies that provide sufficient structure, consistency and protection without imposing unnecessary bureaucracy or becoming disconnected from the company’s actual circumstances.

๐Ÿฅ‹ Dojo Solution

Develop HR policies through a combination of top-down and bottom-up thinking, guided by the company’s objectives, organizational DNA and stage of development.

Neither established HR practices nor the company’s existing working arrangements should be accepted uncritically.

Instead, SMEs should draw upon both sources to create a framework that is appropriate, practical and capable of evolving.

1. The top-down approach: Learn from established practices

The top-down approach begins by examining what effective HR management should look like.

There is considerable value in studying the policies and practices adopted by well-managed organizations, recognized industry leaders and experienced HR professionals.

These can provide useful reference points for addressing matters such as:

  • Recruitment and selection.
  • Employment contracts and onboarding.
  • Compensation and benefits.
  • Working hours, leave and flexible working.
  • Performance management.
  • Employee development and training.
  • Workplace conduct and disciplinary procedures.
  • Equal opportunity and prevention of harassment.
  • Health, safety and employee wellbeing.
  • Grievance handling and dispute resolution.
  • Termination and separation.

The objective is not necessarily to adopt every available policy. Rather, it is to identify the practices that are relevant to the company and determine the standards it should aspire to achieve.

Some policies may be essential from the outset because of legal obligations or significant employment risks. Others may represent desirable management practices that can be introduced progressively as the organization develops.

For example, a small company may not need a sophisticated annual performance management system. However, it should still establish clear expectations, provide feedback and have a reasonably consistent process for addressing performance concerns.

Similarly, a formal succession planning framework may be premature for a company with ten employees, but identifying key-person dependencies is relevant from its earliest days.

The top-down approach helps ensure that important requirements are not overlooked simply because the company has not yet encountered the circumstances that make them necessary.

2. The bottom-up approach: Understand the company’s organizational DNA

The bottom-up approach begins with a different question:

What kind of HR framework will actually work within this particular organization?

This requires an honest assessment of the company’s circumstances, including:

  • Its size and stage of development.
  • Its business model and operating requirements.
  • The nature of its workforce.
  • Its organizational structure and management capabilities.
  • The working relationships between employees and management.
  • Its existing culture and informal practices.
  • Its financial and administrative resources.
  • The expectations and needs of its employees.
  • Its strategic objectives and anticipated growth.

A technology startup employing a small number of highly experienced software developers may have very different HR requirements from a manufacturing SME employing shift workers.

A geographically distributed company may need particularly clear policies regarding remote working, communication and accountability. A rapidly expanding professional services firm may need more structured recruitment, performance management and professional development practices.

The bottom-up approach recognizes that HR policies should reflect these differences.

It also recognizes that the company’s actual organizational DNA may differ from its stated values.

A company might describe itself as collaborative, flexible and entrepreneurial, but its management practices may be highly centralized, its decision-making slow and its employees reluctant to challenge established views.

Simply writing collaborative and entrepreneurial values into an HR manual will not change this reality.

Policies need to be designed with an understanding of how people actually work, interact and make decisions.

The objective is to develop practices that employees and managers can understand, accept and consistently apply.

3. Finding the balance: The practical HR framework

The most effective approach combines the two perspectives.

Top-down thinking establishes the standards and practices that should guide the organization. Bottom-up thinking determines how those standards should be translated into practical arrangements that fit the company’s circumstances.

Consider the following examples:

HR subjectTop-down considerationBottom-up consideration
RecruitmentStructured selection and objective assessmentRecruitment processes appropriate to company size and hiring needs
Performance managementClear objectives and regular feedbackInformal or formal reviews appropriate to management capacity
CompensationFairness, consistency and market competitivenessFinancial capacity, role requirements and internal salary structure
Employee developmentContinuous learning and capability developmentTraining that addresses actual business needs and available resources
Working arrangementsClear expectations and consistent treatmentFlexibility appropriate to the company’s operating model
Organizational cultureEstablished standards of conduct and desired valuesPractices that reflect actual working relationships and company DNA
Employee grievancesFair procedures and appropriate safeguardsAccessible processes that employees can realistically use

The objective is not to compromise important standards to accommodate existing practices.

Nor is it to impose sophisticated procedures simply because they represent conventional HR best practice.

It is to determine how appropriate standards can be achieved through arrangements that work in the company’s particular circumstances.

4. Proportionality: Match HR practices to the stage of development

An additional consideration is the company’s stage of growth.

HR requirements evolve as organizations become larger and more complex.

A useful way to approach this is to distinguish between three broad stages.

Early-stage companies

The priority should be establishing sound foundations.

This includes appropriate employment documentation, clear responsibilities, basic recruitment and onboarding procedures, compensation arrangements, workplace conduct expectations and compliance with applicable employment requirements.

The objective is to avoid creating unnecessary administrative burdens while ensuring that fundamental HR matters are properly addressed.

Growing companies

As employee numbers increase, informal practices become harder to manage.

Greater attention should be given to consistency, management accountability, performance assessment, employee development, communication and the allocation of responsibilities.

The company should begin formalizing practices that may previously have worked through direct relationships with its founders.

More established SMEs

As organizational complexity increases, more sophisticated HR systems may become justified.

These might include structured career development, succession planning, management training, workforce planning, compensation frameworks and more formal performance management.

The important principle is that HR infrastructure should develop alongside the organization.

A policy that is appropriate for a company of fifteen employees may be inadequate for one employing 150. Conversely, adopting the HR infrastructure of a 1,000-person organization when the company has fifteen employees can create unnecessary cost and complexity.

5. Make HR policies part of the operating environment

Finally, HR policies should not exist exclusively in manuals, employment contracts or company intranets.

Their real value comes from influencing everyday organizational behaviour.

A performance management policy is useful only if managers actually provide feedback and address performance issues.

A learning and development policy is meaningful only if employees receive genuine opportunities to develop.

A recruitment policy is effective only if hiring decisions consistently reflect the company’s requirements and standards.

A policy promoting collaboration is of limited value if management practices reward individual competition and discourage information sharing.

This requires HR policies to be translated into practical management routines, responsibilities and expectations.

Employees should understand what the policies mean, managers should know how to implement them, and leadership should demonstrate the behaviours the organization expects.

In this sense, HR policies are not simply administrative instruments. They are mechanisms through which the company establishes and reinforces its organizational DNA.

๐Ÿ—๏ธ Putting It into Practice

SMEs can develop a balanced HR framework through the following steps.

Step 1: Establish the company’s HR objectives

Begin by considering what the company needs its HR framework to achieve.

These objectives should be linked to the company’s broader business strategy.

For example:

  • Recruit people with the capabilities required to execute the business plan.
  • Establish a working environment that attracts and retains capable employees.
  • Encourage accountability, initiative and collaboration.
  • Develop the capabilities required for future growth.
  • Establish consistent and fair employment practices.
  • Protect the company and its employees against avoidable employment risks.

The objective is to make HR policy a contributor to business performance rather than an isolated administrative function.

Step 2: Identify the essential HR requirements

Develop an inventory of the HR matters that the company needs to address.

Review relevant employment laws and regulatory requirements in every jurisdiction in which the company operates.

Distinguish between:

  • Mandatory legal and regulatory requirements.
  • Important risk-management and employee-protection measures.
  • Good management practices.
  • Aspirational practices that may be introduced as the company grows.

This distinction is important. Legal obligations and essential employee protections should not be treated as optional merely because the company is small or has limited resources.

Step 3: Research established HR practices

Identify relevant policies and practices used by reputable organizations and recognized HR professionals.

Consider which approaches would provide useful standards for your company.

Avoid simply copying entire HR manuals. Instead, identify the underlying objectives of individual policies and the problems they are designed to address.

Ask whether the company needs the same level of formality, whether the procedure can be simplified and whether the underlying standard can be achieved through a more appropriate arrangement.

Step 4: Conduct an organizational reality assessment

Examine how the company actually operates.

Speak with management and employees. Understand the nature of their work, their expectations, the challenges they encounter and the informal arrangements that have developed.

Identify practices that are working well and should be preserved.

Also identify inconsistencies, weaknesses and areas where existing arrangements may become problematic as the company grows.

This exercise should be conducted honestly. It is important to distinguish between the culture management believes exists and the culture employees actually experience.

Step 5: Develop tailored policies and procedures

Combine the findings from the previous steps.

For each important HR subject, determine:

  1. What standard should the company seek to achieve?
  2. What are its actual operational requirements?
  3. What procedure would achieve the desired standard?
  4. Who will be responsible for implementing it?
  5. What resources and management capabilities are required?

Keep policies clear, proportionate and accessible.

Avoid unnecessary complexity, but do not sacrifice important standards or legal protections in the pursuit of simplicity.

Step 6: Integrate policies into everyday management

Once the framework is established, communicate it to employees and managers.

Provide practical guidance on how policies should be implemented.

In particular, ensure that managers understand their responsibilities and that employees know where to find information and raise questions or concerns.

In a small company, the founder or managing director may initially be responsible for most HR matters. As the company grows, responsibilities can be delegated appropriately.

The objective is to make HR policies part of normal management practice rather than an additional administrative exercise.

Step 7: Review and evolve the framework

HR policies should not be regarded as permanent documents.

Review them periodically and whenever there are significant changes in the company’s size, structure, business model or operating environment.

Ask employees and managers whether the policies are working as intended.

Identify procedures that have become unnecessary, policies that are not being followed and areas where additional structure is required.

Most importantly, consider whether the HR framework continues to support the company’s strategic objectives and organizational DNA.

The best HR framework is one that develops with the company rather than becoming an obstacle to its development.

๐Ÿ“Œ Key Takeaways

  • Start early: HR practices begin influencing organizational culture and employee expectations from the company’s first hires.
  • Avoid blind imitation: Policies designed for large organizations may be inappropriate or unnecessarily complicated for SMEs.
  • Avoid excessive informality: Practices that work in a small team may become inconsistent and inadequate as the company grows.
  • Use top-down thinking: Learn from established HR practices, professional standards and proven management approaches.
  • Use bottom-up thinking: Understand the company’s actual needs, working relationships, management capabilities and organizational DNA.
  • Balance the two: Adopt appropriate standards while tailoring their implementation to the company’s circumstances.
  • Apply proportionality: HR infrastructure should develop alongside the company’s size, complexity and stage of growth.
  • Connect HR with strategy: Recruitment, development, performance and retention should support the capabilities required to achieve business objectives.
  • Focus on implementation: HR policies create value when they influence everyday behaviour, not simply when they exist in written form.
  • Keep evolving: An effective HR framework should be regularly reviewed and adapted as the organization develops.

๐ŸŒฟ Reflection

Consider the HR policies and practices within your organization.

Are they genuinely designed around the company’s objectives, people and operating environment? Or have they largely been borrowed from other organizations without sufficient consideration of whether they are appropriate?

Conversely, are you relying too heavily on informal arrangements that may have worked in the past but are becoming increasingly difficult to manage?

Perhaps the more important question is whether your HR policies reflect the organization you actually have, the organization you want to become and the people you need to get there.

A good HR framework should provide sufficient structure to establish consistency, fairness and accountability while preserving the flexibility and entrepreneurial spirit that may have contributed to the company’s success.

The objective is not to build the HR department of a large corporation. It is to build the HR framework that your company needs to become the organization it aspires to be.

โš”๏ธ Dojo Mission

Conduct a short HR Policy Audit.

Select three important HR areas within your company, such as recruitment, performance management and employee development.

For each area:

  1. Identify one established HR practice that could provide a useful standard.
  2. Assess whether your company’s current arrangements adequately address the underlying objective.
  3. Identify one practical modification that would make the practice more appropriate to your company’s actual circumstances.
  4. Determine who should be responsible for implementing it.

Choose one improvement and put it into practice this month.

Remember: The objective is not to have the most comprehensive HR manual. It is to have an HR framework that your people understand, your managers can implement and your organization genuinely lives.


Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *